Young Adult Lit/Crit

March 26, 2008

Feeling the Heat

Filed under: Fahreneheit 451 — traverse02 @ 4:25 pm

I would like to start off discussion on Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury by relating a very interesting item of news that developed in the fall of 2004 in Buffalo, NY. I was an undergrad at SUNY Buffalo at the time, working for the student-run magazine, Generation, when the big story hit that Erie County would be suffering from a $130 million deficit in 2005. The county’s immediate reaction in proposing a budget? Cut funding for and close all of the county’s 52 libraries. You can read a more detailed account of what happened by clicking here. Fortunately, the green budget was passed. As a result, the county libraries reduced their services. Many libraries closed, and many librarians and other county workers lost their jobs. It was a moment that reminded me of some of the great sci-fi stories I had read over the years, especially Fahrenheit 451. Just think about it, the libraries being the first thing the county legislature decides to let go of when faced with a budget crisis. They might as well have proposed burning the books as a source of energy. The way I see it, taking away such a valuable community service as the public library system would have been the ultimate blow against the youth of that county. The Buffalo/Erie County area is a very poor area. The kids going through the school system don’t have the technology or many of the other resources that more privileged students have. Taking away the libraries would have been a terrible blow, not only to them, but to any card carrying library member.

I wish I could say that all is well for Erie County Libraries, but they suffered from significant cut-backs in staff and hours of operation. To this day, I find the whole thing ridiculous and worry about what the government will decide is good for us in the harsh times ahead.

So, my main question for everyone in discussing Fahrenheit 451 is this: Where does it all begin? Are we living in a time that is much different than the supposed future world that is depicted in the book? Think of high-definition flat screen TVs hung on the walls in homes across America, taking the place of artwork and family photos. Is that radically different from Mildred Montag’s world? And the reality television… What is it that Mildred watches on the walls? Seem familiar?

Bradbury was hitting very close to home back in 1953 when this novel was published, and I can’t help but feel that the world he envisioned has come to be a reality, to a certain extent. Granted, we aren’t burning books, but considering what happened in Buffalo and the likelihood of the same thing happening somewhere else, we educators should be unsettled. Imagine how difficult it would be to teach an English class without the aid of local libraries, especially in poorer areas where families can barely afford their children’s education let alone books. Will we teachers become like Guy Montag and Faber, holders of information that has been long forgotten/banned/burned? Will we ultimately go back to the beginning and become oral storytellers all over again, like in ancient days?

It seems possible. Maybe not to the extent represented in the book, but maybe. That’s what I dig most about sci-fi, is the maybe. It could get that bad, it could turn out for the better. Nevertheless, the issues addressed in Fahrenheit 451 are very real and help put modern society in some sort of perspective.

I look forward to hearing what you all think.
Until tomorrow,




  1. Raph,

    astounding story about the Erie County Libraries. That would be a good story to jot down, and get out on the market. Bridging non-fiction and sci-fi, what would we call that? Um, Allison, help me out.

    I completely agree with your Mildred/big-screen t.v. connection to present day. Also, I enjoyed two aspects of her “reality programming:” a) that she called her programs “her family” and b) that her fav was “the white clown.” This evoked for me not only white as the color of mourning, but also a clown as a tragic figure of comedy. Great combo there. In my imagination, the white clown (although he was a dancer) was ematiated. And scarey.

    Can’t wait to talk more about it.


    Comment by joycehansen — March 26, 2008 @ 8:18 pm

  2. I was appalled to read that story about the libraries (sorry this post is delayed) but like you said in our discussion Raph, this novel isn’t really about the future because of situations like these. How scary is it to think that the next step could be portrayed in 451 as a near reality? Frightening…

    Anyways… I really enjoyed the discussion that myself, Raph, Jonathan, and Helen (seriously, how cute was she?) had on the novel, especially after listening to Ray Bradbury live in the interview. We discussed some pretty relevent topics such as the “dumbing down of America” and contributors such as reality television. Additionally we discussed Raph’s posting on the libraries being shut down. I can’t believe I had to “skip” this novel in high school (along with the long list of others) to read Sir Gawain and the Green Knight… ugh! (Don’t get me wrong- I enjoy it now, but as a 16-year-old? Seriously? That class should have been “How to get a enthusiastic reader to hate reading 101” but alas, I am off topic: Karen feel free to throw out your red flag!!) Such a relevant topic, especially in the age of Kindle! I have had my more earth conscious (non-reader) friends become blanched when they see my bookshelves and I am sure they are counting the numbers of trees I have destroyed personally… What does the future of the book look like? Can we be optimistic about the longevity of paper media?

    Comment by kariredmond — March 31, 2008 @ 10:30 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

%d bloggers like this: